Right Major + Right College = Career Success - Helping you get where you were meant to be.
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Delivered by FeedBurner

Recent Posts

Biggest Problem for Accepted Students
Will My College Be Open?
College in the Era of Covid
Student Loan Interest Rates Drop for 2020-21
Not All Info on the Web about FAFSA is Accurate

Most Popular Posts

Essay Topic: What will you contribute to our campus?
Got an IEP? Don't forget to take it to college.
Discouraging Words
Will Social Media Affect Your Child's Chances?
What to do when things change


Accepted? Now What?
Admission Decisions
Admission Essays
Adult Students
Athletes and College
Campus Safety
Career Planning and College
Choosing the best college for you
College Admission Deadlines
College Admission Decisions
College Admission Essays
College Admission Tests
College application process
College Applications
College Buyer Beware
College Camp
College Choice
College Costs
College Counseling and Advising
College Entrance Exams
College Freshman Adjustment
College Graduation and Beyond
College Major
College Myths
College Prep
College Prep Opportunities
College Recruitment
College Scholarships
College succcess
College Transfer
Early preparation for college
Education Consumerism
FInancial Aid
Financial Aid and Scholarships
GAP Year
GAP Year and Summer Programs
Getting in....or not
Good advice
Grad School
Graduate to a Job
Highly Selective Colleges
It's all in the timing
Kids Today
Learning Disability Accommodations
Media Treatment of College Information
Money and College
Online College
Parent and Grandparent Support
Parent and Grandparent Support in the College Process
Parent and student relationships in the college process
Parenting Teens
Picking a college
Planning for College Success
Positioning Students for Success
Social Media and College
Start Planning Early
Student Development
Student Loan Debt
Student Loans
Student Posts About Their Experiences
Success Hints
Summer Activities
Summer college prep
Surviving fall semester fo the senior year
The College-Job Connection
The Junior Year
To-do lists
Value of College
powered by

College Talk Blog

Some articles about college may unintentionally mislead parents

On March 26, 2014, Atlantic Monthly published an article about the value of degrees from certain US colleges and majors entitled: These U.S. Colleges and Majors Are the Biggest Waste of Money. The basis of the article was income data from Pay Scale. The article, which provides a list of colleges and majors that are alleged to be a waste of money, was written by Derek Thompson, a senior editor at Atlantic Monthly.

I like the Atlantic Monthly but am tired of articles that mislead parents. Parents reading the article may decide not to send their children to a long list of fine colleges and universities which includes California State University at Northridge,  Virginia Commonwealth University, Ohio State University, East Carolina University, Old Dominion University, University of North Carolina at Asheville, University of Central Florida and the State University of New York at Buffalo.

Based on this article, parents may also be concerned if their children want to major in degrees in humanities, criminal justice, social work or education. While these are programs where graduates often earn lower salaries than technology degrees for example, majors should no more be labeled a waste of money than should universities.

While articles like this attract attention, it would be better if they were more careful about the conclusions they draw and less sensational about the headlines they use. The parents of this year's high school juniors and seniors, very concerned about education outcomes for their investment, deserve better. Let the reader beware.


1 Comment to Some articles about college may unintentionally mislead parents:

Comments RSS
submariner rolex on Thursday, December 25, 2014 4:51 AM
Excellent post however I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this topic? I'd be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it!
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment